16 Car Innovations That Hit a Dead End: A Journey Through Automotive Missteps

Innovation in the automotive industry has often been marked by a combination of genius and audacity. Yet, not all ideas have made it to the road—and some that did, quickly ran out of gas. Here, we explore ten car innovations that, despite their initial promise, hit a dead end.

1. **Bose Electromagnetic Suspension**: When Bose, renowned for its audio products, ventured into car suspension systems, it was a bold move. Dr. Amar Bose envisioned a suspension system that balanced between air-sprung and hydropneumatic technologies. The ‘active’ suspension utilized computer-controlled electromagnetic motors that reacted swiftly to road conditions. Despite its impressive performance showcased in a 1994 Lexus LS400, the system’s cost and complexity prevented widespread adoption. Though the technology was later spun off into truck seats, it remains largely unused in the automotive industry.

2. **Polyurethane (Plastic) Tyres**: Austrian company Polyair introduced ‘LIM’ tyres, aiming to simplify tyre production through injection-molded polyurethane. These tyres were resilient to punctures, heat-resistant, and could be produced in varied colors. Despite successful trials and interest, the innovation struggled due to poor handling characteristics and resistance from the established tyre industry. The technology found limited success in non-automotive applications, such as supermarket trolleys and forklifts.

3. **Wind-down Rear Windscreens**: Before air-conditioning became standard, Ford and Austin experimented with retractable rear windscreens in the 1950s. The feature, known as ‘Breezeway,’ appeared on select Mercury models, offering ventilation but also allowing road debris and odors into the cabin. The rise of affordable air-conditioning systems eventually rendered this quirky feature obsolete, now cherished only by collectors.

4. **Cast-Aluminium Frame Construction**: In the 1950s, Jean-Albert Grégoire’s idea of using a cast-aluminium frame for cars promised weight reduction and corrosion resistance. The Hotchkiss-Grégoire utilized this method but was costly and time-consuming to produce. Despite its advanced engineering, the unattractive design and high price led to its downfall, ultimately unable to compete with more conventionally built vehicles.

5. **Prismatic Side Mirrors**: Developed in the 1990s, de Montfort prismatic side mirrors offered reduced drag and eliminated blind spots without electronic aids. Despite theoretical benefits and appearances on concept cars, regulatory hurdles stalled their mainstream adoption. Modern cars have instead embraced digital solutions like cameras, leaving this purely mechanical innovation behind.

6. **In-car Record Players**: Chrysler’s ‘Highway Hi-Fi’ brought music to the road with in-car record players in the 1950s. However, the practical challenges of playing records in a moving car, including skipping and inconvenience, led to its quick demise. The advent of more reliable music formats like cassettes and CDs replaced this fleeting innovation.

7. **In-car Motorcycles**: Honda’s Motorcompo, a fold-up motorcycle designed to fit in the trunk of its City car, was introduced in the early 1980s. Despite its clever concept, it never caught on due to limited utility and safety concerns. However, it remains a cult favorite among enthusiasts, more for its novelty than practicality.

8. **Hayes Selfselector CVT**: The Hayes Selfselector offered a form of continuously variable transmission in the 1930s, simplifying driving by eliminating gear changes. However, the high cost and maintenance issues saw it phased out before World War II. While CVT technology eventually found success in modern cars, Hayes’ innovation was too ahead of its time.

9. **Miller Cycle Engines**: The Miller Cycle, used by Mazda in its Xedos 9, promised increased fuel efficiency by modifying the traditional combustion cycle. Despite its engineering merits, the technology failed to gain traction in the market, though its principles influenced later engine designs.

10. **Lean-burn Engines**: Aimed at improving fuel economy, lean-burn engines mixed more air with fuel for a ‘leaner’ combustion. Although tried by various companies, changing emissions laws, particularly regarding NOx reduction, led to their decline. While the technology provided insights into fuel management, it was ultimately outpaced by other emission control methods.

These ten innovations, while initially heralded as the next big thing, serve as reminders of the ever-evolving nature of automotive technology. The road to progress is paved with experimentation, and sometimes, that means veering off course.

11. **Front-Mounted Horse’s Head**: Imagine a time when automobiles were a newfangled technology and horses ruled the roads. To bridge the gap between old and new, some manufacturers attached a horse’s head to the front of their vehicles to comfort those hesitant new drivers. While the idea was a hit in 1899, this innovation quickly trotted away into obscurity due to its impractical nature and safety concerns.

12. **Children’s Partition**: Being stuck in a car with kids during long road trips can test even the most patient parents. In the 1940s and ’50s, automakers introduced partitions between front and rear car seats aiming to provide peace for parents. However, the idea didn’t catch on as many parents preferred to keep an eye (and ear) on their children, making this innovation more of a novelty than a necessity.

13. **Nuclear Fusion Engines**: In a world obsessed with futuristic ideas, the 1950s and ’60s saw automakers experimenting with nuclear fusion engines. Ford’s Nucleon concept car envisioned a car powered by a miniature nuclear reactor. While the idea was certainly innovative, the potential dangers and costs involved left this concept on the drawing board, a relic of the atomic age.

14. **A Fifth Wheel for Parking**: Maneuvering into tight parking spaces has challenged drivers since the dawn of the car. Enter the fifth wheel—a car innovation designed to simplify parallel parking. This extra wheel, deployed when needed, would allow cars to pivot into parking spaces. Despite its clever concept, the complexity and cost prevented this innovation from rolling out widely.

15. **The Hover Car**: Hover cars have long been a staple of science fiction. In reality, multiple attempts to create a hover car have been made, but none have succeeded in practical application. High costs, technological limitations, and regulatory challenges have kept hover cars a dream rather than a reality, though they continue to inspire visions of futuristic travel.

16. **Amphibious Cars**: Amphibious cars are designed to operate on both land and water, a truly innovative concept that has sparked curiosity for decades. While some models made it to production, the difficulty in balancing performance on both terrains meant these cars were often neither great nor practical, relegating them to niche roles rather than mainstream success.

Related posts:
10 Bizarre Car Innovations That Thankfully Failed
10 Awesome Car Technologies That Never Took Off
The CAR Top 10: US innovation hits and misses